Salted Caramel Apple Pie from Whidbey Pies | SeaBear Smokehouse

Brunch favorites, baked treats & more are 20% off — Shop Now

Brunch favorites, baked treats & more are 20% off — Shop Now

Brunch favorites, baked treats & more are 20% off — Shop Now

Brunch favorites, baked treats & more are 20% off — Shop Now

20% Off In-Cart

Salted Caramel Apple Pie from Whidbey Pies

$29

- +
  • 9" Pie
  • Ships Frozen
  • Pre-Baked | Reheat
  • Serves: 8

Handmade locally on Whidbey Island with real fruit and a golden-brown crust, Whidbey Pies are made with whole ingredients for a classic homemade taste. The Salted Caramel Apple Pie features a juicy apple filling topped with salted caramel drizzle and crystal sea salt, paired with a flaky crust made with organic coconut oil and butter.

SKU 2-87552

Whidbey Pies are handmade using whole ingredients, with each pie offering its own unique appearance. The fruit filling focuses on real fruit rather than thickeners, giving every bite a juicy texture and fresh fruit flavor. Made with organic coconut oil and butter, the crust bakes to a golden brown and may bubble over during baking, creating the pies’ signature homemade look. Some varieties feature additional toppings, such as salted caramel drizzle and large-crystal sea salt.

Your pie arrives fully baked and should arrive frozen. Keep frozen until ready to bake.

Baking from Frozen:
Preheat oven to 350°F. Place frozen pie on the center rack and bake for approximately 60–90 minutes, until the fruit is bubbling and the crust is golden.

Thawing & Reheating:
Thaw completely on the counter or in the refrigerator. Remove all packaging and place the pie on a baking sheet. Warm in a preheated oven at 250°F for 20 minutes. Let rest for a few minutes before slicing.

Serve at room temperature or gently warmed. Pair with a scoop of ice cream, if desired.

salted caramel apple pie

salted caramel apple pie

Overall rating: 4.7777777 / 5 from 18 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Summary topics

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

Reviews

These pies are the best,

"These pies are the best, I have sent them to family, friends and to my family. They are delivered with great care, thank you for making them available. Sincerely, Pat Przebieglec"

— Anonymous (5/5)

It arrived unfrozen and leaking

"It arrived unfrozen and leaking juice everywhere. Normally these are good."

— Pamela H. (2/5)

The best!

"The best!"

— Bill H. (5/5)

Great Company

"My order was delayed; dry ice melted. The pies were a mess. Called and explained. Was sent replacements in overnight mail. Marionberry pies were delicious. Thank you for being such a courteous and responsible company."

— Mary F. (5/5)

"Amazing tasting pies"

— Chris (5/5)

Delicious

"I received a Marionberry pie as part of a recent SeaBear mystery box, and I'm so glad I did! I'm not sure I would have taken a chance and ordered the pie in one of my usual orders, because, well, I'd never had a Whidbey Pie so I didn't know how wonderful they are. Baked as directed, including adding a bit of egg wash and sugar to the top, this pie was really delightful, with the delicious marionberry filling and a really delicious crust-- nicely browned, flaky and a bit sweet, just perfect."

— Emms (5/5)

good pie

"when i saw this i had to have it. many years since visiting whidbey island where i first had marionberry pie. this is a good pie and i enjoyed it but for it to be an excellent pie it needs to be thicker. not disappointed though. i will try the marionberry cobbler next. tillamook makes marionberry ice cream which i want to try also but that flavor hasnt reached my area yet. love marionberries"

— celia k. (4/5)

Great Pies. SeaBear is an honorable company with excellent quality, business & shipping to Hawaii (June 2023)

"SeaBear honored "free shipping" for my June order to Honolulu after kindly informing me that a computer error allowed my order to have free shipping. Carrie informed me that there is always flat rate shipping to Honolulu. After the Whidbey pies arrived, Dannon and Carrie of the Customer Care Team responded to my email and photos quickly and corrected a damaged shipment and sent 2 replacement pies and didn't charge me for the replacement shipping. The replacement Whidbey frozen pies when baked per instructions (I didn't sprinkle with sugar) were flakey and full of fruit, as good as home made. The Marion Berry was sweeter than the Triple Berry, both excellent. I experimented and baked the damaged pies (see below for damage description) that had partially thawed and, as warned by customer representatives, the results were "weird" and less than half of these pies were useable. So keeping the pies frozen until baking is essential. The original pie order for 6 Triple Berry Pies arrived with 4 pies in a large foam container that was inside a shipping cardboard box, and 2 pies in a second cardboard box with interior insulation. Both had dry ice that was mostly gone by the time the shipments arrived. The largest foam container box arrived damaged and 2 of 4 pies had damaged plastic clam-shell containers and the pastry was dented and filling partially thawed. SeaBear quickly and kindly corrected the problem. I would order from SeaBear again without reservation."

— Cindy (5/5)

Marionberry all the way!

"Marionberry all the way! Sent pies to my kids in Ohio who are GAGA over Whidbey Pies when the visit Whidbey Island! Thank you for this great service!"

— Lori (5/5)

Superb!

"These pies should come with a warning label that they can be highly addictive - I believe we've ordered 12 of them since last Thanksgiving. Seabear packages them excellently - they time deliveries so that they are never just sitting in a delivery truck or in a warehouse over the weekend. Thank-you Seabear for such a delightful taste on berries from the Pacific Northwest!"

— Paul (5/5)

Q&A